Tuesday, August 16, 2005
Tuesday, August 09, 2005
"HR has to fall in Love with the business not HR itself"
'HR has to fall in love with the business not HR itself'
In their new book,The HR Value Proposition, Wayne Brockbank and Dave Ulrich, professors at the University of Michigan School of Business, explore the HR discipline's Holy Grail: making human resources a strategic partner to business. Indrajit Gupta met up with professor Brockbank for a discussion on the new book and other critical HR issues. He was accompanied by Satish Pradhan, HR head of the Tata Group. Professor Ulrich joined the chat through a tele-conference.
IndrajitGupta:What triggered your new book?
Wayne Brockbank: For the last decade or so, we have been thinking about what it means for HR to be a true business partner. That statement itself implies that it should not begin with HR logic, but with business logic. Therefore, the key issue became: what is required for a business to be successful? To succeed, a business has to ensure that its two key constituents (external customers and shareholders) are happy. If HR cannot align with those externally-driven requirements and bring internal stakeholders (management and employees) in line with the external stakeholders,then it isn't a business partner.In 1997, a colleague from Argentina did a dissertation with us and came to a very interesting conclusion using our dataset and human resource competencies at the university. He found that knowledge of HR does not distinguish HR professionals at high-performing firms from those in low-performing firms. And that external knowledge, not internal knowledge of HR, is the key differentiator. Most HR professionals have a low level of external business reality - customers, competitors, shareholders, industry structures, globalisation and all the things that make business what it is. It was a very interesting finding. So we had two starting points for our thinking. First, HR aspires to be a business partner. And second, to be a business partner, it needs to create a line of sight to the outside. Our empirical research here shed additional light. Over the last 18 years, we have gathered the largest dataset of HR professionals. Put together, all that provides a very compelling argument for creating the HR value proposition. And, of course, the title of the book is taken from the concept of business value proposition, which starts from the outside and moves towards the inside. With that in mind, we decided to pool our thoughts, experiences and the best practices - gleaned during our consulting and research work - into creating one powerful package.
IG: Why did HR get marginalised, especially at a time when the traditional sources of competitive advantage were eroding? What did HR need to do to be able to sit at the same table and have the same influence as other departments?
WB: The missing piece was the fundamental appreciation we talked about earlier. Nothing of what happens inside matters, unless it happens to matter to somebody outside. We call that the 'Wallet Test' in the book. Unless HR can create an exact line of sight, not an ambiguous line, between its activities and getting customers to take money out from their wallet and put it in your wallet, instead of the competitor's wallet, it doesn't contribute to the success of a business, and therefore, does not matter.HR needs that line of sight to create the human side of the business - the culture, capabilities, technical knowledge and skills that enable people to create products and services better than the competitors. With this, we are holding HR up to the same standards on which other departments are held. Why does the product development department exist? To create products and services that result in customers taking out money out of their wallets. The same is true for marketing, sales, manufacturing and so on. If HR is to be an essential part of the business, it has to align with the external business realities.Two factors have inhibited HR's ability to function as a business partner: its logic and its language. For example, HR likes to say it has internal customers. When it takes that vocabulary and logic to the strategy table, it automatically condemns itself to a second tier status.At the strategy table, when the business partners say: "How do we make the customer happy?" they are actually asking: "How do we take money out of the customer's wallet into our wallet and make them happier with us than with our competitors?" When HR walks into the room and says that it has internal customers, it is immediately removed from the basic logic and language of the business. The logic and language of the business is the external customer. This is also the logic and language of HR professionals in high performing firms.
IG: But CEOs sometimes don't allow HR to play the role it can...
WB: My experience has been overwhelmingly that the demand for strategic HR far exceeds the supply. It was a conclusion vividly conveyed to me by the senior HR vice-president of one of the five largest companies in North America. I asked her the traditional consulting question: "What keeps you up at night?" She said: "Ten years ago, given the state of strategic HR at the time, our supply exceeded the demand. Today, the demand so far exceeds the supply that it threatens to be a fundamental source of competitive disadvantage of the company." In the University of Michigan, we have seen a huge increase in the number of senior line executives enrolling in our executive programmes on how to create and engage the human side of business - how to conceptualise and create the total human organisation. Furthermore, these issues are increasingly preoccupying the senior thought leaders throughout the strategy community, the best of whom is C.K. Prahalad.
The changes in the world of business require companies to pay more attention to the human side of the business. Many other sources of competitive advantage have gone by the wayside. The shelf life of technological know-how has dropped through the floor. The critical issue now is not what you know, but what you are able to create. Institutionalised creativity is a central cultural issue and is, therefore, an HR issue. Also, how well a company can execute self-standing platforms of technology, products and services is being replaced by the leveraging of common technologies, products and services across business units. This business trend may also be called the culture of cooperation, synergy and convergence. These should be central agendas of HR. The human resource department should be responsible for recruiting, promoting and developing high-quality leaders who will take the company to greater levels of success.Thus, the world is telling HR: 'We need to have you add greater value.' But if you need to have that, you need to start from the business standpoint, and not the HR standpoint. I once had a student ask me for a letter of recommendation for a leading HR graduate programme in the US. This was an extremely gifted young man. He graduated from one of the leading schools with almost a perfect GPA. I told him: "You have the ability to be one of the best in the field, is that your aspiration?" He said: "Yes." Then I said: "If you want to be really good in HR, get an MBA. Work in line management for two or three years and then go into HR, and you will be fabulous." His response was: "I don't want to go into business. I want to go into HR." At one level, there is nothing wrong with that. But at another level, something is centrally wrong with his logic. His identity was first in HR and then in business. If HR is to contribute to business, it has to break out of that way of thinking; it has to fall in love with the business rather than human resource.
IG: Coming back to the notion of what the HR leadership will be all about, what does your research really tell us?
WB: The good news is we don't have to guess anymore. In our most recent research, we have asked two questions. What are the competencies and capabilities of the HR professionals? And what are the competencies of HR that distinguish high performing firms from low performing firms? The latter is the more interesting of the two questions.We have found that there are five categories of HR capabilities and competencies: HR professionals need to make strategic contributions; have personal credibility; deliver the basic HR practices of staffing, training, developing and measuring performance; have business knowledge; and they need to be fluent with the application of information technology to HR. The first of these five categories is strategic contribution. Of HR's total impact on business performance, 43 per cent is accounted for by strategic contribution. That consists of: first, designing and creating the cultural infrastructure that creates sustained competitive advantage. Second, managing rapid change. Third, adding value through contributions to the strategy forums and discussions in the company. Fourth, creating an organisation that is focused on responding to and being unified around external market needs.
We also know how to make each of these happen. Culture management is the most statistically significant of all HR practices that impacts all business practices. Successful HR professionals align their HR practices to create the culture that drives business success. An interesting conclusion can be deduced. Delivery of the HR basic practices accounts for only 18 per cent of differentiating variance between high performers and low performers. That includes the basic HR infrastructure practices. When they are done in a tactical and reactionary manner and when they are done without a definitive business focus, they account for 18 per cent of HR's influence on business results. But when those same practices are designed and implemented in the context of HR's strategic contribution as described above, that 18 per cent jumps to 43 per cent. That's about a 250 per cent increase in HR's impact on business. Doing HR practices with a clearly targeted culture-based business agenda creates great results.
The major inhibitor to HR adding this kind of value is the trap of being internally focused - thinking in terms of internal customers and not focusing on the results that the marketplace requires. In our dataset, we asked senior line executives to evaluate HR professionals in terms of their over-competencies. I consider this to be an indicator of HR's internal popularity. To be internally popular, HR professionals need to have personal credibility; they need to do the basics; do what they say they will do and; have good interpersonal and communication skills. But while these competencies will increase the internal popularity of an HR professional, they have a mediocre impact on business performance. Thus, what an HR professional does to be internally popular is very different from what he must do to push the business ahead.
IG: Any advice for HR professionals?
WB: My first advice: have a great sense of urgency about your own focus on business. Second, HR professionals in India must think in terms of being more effective at their jobs than their counterparts in the US and Europe. US and European companies have the competitive momentum to carry themselves to Indian markets; likewise, Indian companies must be good enough to carry themselves to these markets. Such is the nature of global competition. Indian HR professionals cannot think about benchmarking Indian practices; they must be knowledgeable about best practices outside India. They must also think about next generation practices and be more powerfully competitive than their counterparts. Five or six years ago, the head of staffing at Cisco stated: "Our product life cycle is six to nine months. If we are not changing our HR practices as fast as the product life cycle, then we are not contributing to the competitive advantage of the company. If, we in HR, are doing the same things that we were doing nine months ago, then we are probably doing what everyone else is doing. That just isn't good enough, isn't just adequate."
IG: Professor Ulrich, how does your earlier work on HR roles tie in with your current research with Professor Brockbank?
DU: The roles we talked about in HR Champions (HBS Press, 1997) were defined as deliverables. The deliverable of the employee champion role is employee commitment. The deliverable of the administrative expert role is efficiency. The change agent deliverable is making change happen. The deliverable of the strategic partner role is making strategy happen. Each role had to make something happen. Wayne talked to you about world trends in the economy - India, Europe and North America. Those trends have shifted what those deliverables have to be. So we now believe that those roles have to be tied with the trends in the economy.We see, more than ever before, that the employee advocate role must help employees feel cared for. Through the years, I am convinced that people need to have meaning and relationship in their personal and professional lives. The employee advocate works not just to get people to work harder, but to have meaning, relationships and hope in their professional lives.The human capital role focuses on helping employees prepare for the future. As human capital becomes more central to productivity and improvement, HR professionals functioning in this role become more critical. The functional expert delivers efficient HR processes. Some of these efficiencies come through technology and some through service centres. Whatever the channel, HR must become more efficient and the HR personnel members need to be experts.The strategic partner role is more than just managing change. It also includes knowledge sharing, collaboration and strategy implementation. The strategic partner role also focuses on developing key capabilities that the company needs for success. Finally, as HR professionals function in the leadership role, they serve as role models. Wayne and I aren't sure if these roles are the right five. But we do believe that the human capital developer roles are hugely critical.
IG: Among the high performing organisations you have researched, how much has that shift played out? Do you see them clearly moving away from the administrative kind of roles, and focusing instead on more strategic dimensions?
DU: The answer is yes and no. That is a great academic answer! I think Wayne may have a slightly different view, but I feel that resources have been split into halves. Half of HR work is administrative transaction work - hiring, training, benefits, facilities management. That takes 80 per cent of its time and attention. That will be reduced by outsourcing, technology and service centres.When that is done, the whole second half of HR - transformation, innovative or strategic work will get a lot more attention. That's where HR professionals are coaches, architects, designers, and facilitators who can really begin to transform business strategy into a set of capabilities and actions. In the future, there will be fewer HR people but these few individuals will be much more qualified to do what Wayne has talked about in our research.
Satish Pradhan: You have the insight and foresight of the initiatives that help companies stay ahead in the game. Could you pick one or two of the practices or initiatives that will be the most significant in the next decade?
DU: I am going to be bold and pick free three. Maybe the first two are what matter most. Each one is built on a myth. The first one is that competitiveness is not strategy. The CEO needs to compete. The world is becoming even more competitive. Competing is not just building a strategy, it is having an organisation that will deliver the strategy better than your competitors. We can't compete by just knowing where we are going. We compete by getting there. Two, organisation is not structure. It is a set of capabilities. When I teach, I ask people to pick a company they admire. Assume for a moment that someone picks a Tata company. How many levels of management does a Tata company have? Nobody knows and nobody cares. An organisation is not evaluated by the number of levels. It is deemed successful if it has a successful set of capabilities. A Tata company may be very good at leveraging diversity, collaborating across businesses, or be very good at speed. But it is capabilities that make the Tatas good. I think HR's job is to do an organisational diagnosis that begins with the process of identifying and building key capabilities. The third insight is that HR is not a practice, but an integrated set of practices that join together to create capabilities and allows strategies to happen. HR professionals build capabilities into the organisation when they have integrated HR practices. When this is done, HR benefits not only employees, who feel valued and engaged, but also customers and investors. And when we follow those three premises, HR benefits an entire network of stakeholders.
Source:http://www.businessworldindia.com/AUG1505/indepth03.asp
Ajit Chouhan
Friday, August 05, 2005
Sunday, July 31, 2005
Sunday, July 24, 2005
Monday, July 18, 2005
Saturday, July 16, 2005
Thursday, July 14, 2005
INFLUENCE OF EMOTIONS ON TRUST
Looking to Make a Sale or Get Promoted? Emotions Will Help Determine the Outcome .
High emotion contributes to great opera. It does not, however, serve us well when making judgments about others. This is the argument advanced in "Feeling and Believing: The Influence of Emotion on Trust," a new paper by Maurice E. Schweitzer, Wharton professor of operations and information management, and Jennifer Dunn, a PhD student in the department.
The two researchers conducted five experiments to determine the influence of emotional states -- happiness, gratitude, anger, and guilt -- on trust. Each experiment confirmed that incidental emotions (emotions from one situation that influence judgment in a following, unrelated situation) affect how willing we are to trust others. For example, our anger over a speeding ticket is likely to affect how we judge someone later in the day. The researchers conclude that despite feeling we are rational beings who make clear, lucid judgments, in reality we all walk around in a sea of emotions that are likely to influence how we act in both business and social contexts.
The article, recently published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, stems from Schweitzer's ongoing interest in negotiation, where trust plays a critical role. Previous research identified trust as a combination of two constructs: one's own propensity to trust and one's knowledge about the other person. "This research suggests that we make a cognitive decision and use reason to decide whether or not to trust someone," notes Schweitzer. "What our research says is that trust is much more labile than that."
In other words, trust is a constructed judgment that is influenced by irrelevant information. "The extent to which I do or do not trust you is a function not only of how trusting a person I am and what I know about you, but also a function of irrelevant events that have influenced my emotional state. For example, if I hit a parked car, argued with my spouse, learned that I have to pay a large repair bill (or won an award, had a paper accepted, or saw my stock account grow) beforehand, I would trust you less (or more). The main idea in the paper is that emotions which are irrelevant to the judgment task nevertheless influence trust judgments in predictable ways," Schweitzer says.
He and Dunn demonstrated this through a series of experiments, each one designed to test a different aspect of the "emotions affect trust" theory. In one study, for example, he and his team approached people waiting for trains and asked if they would be willing to take part in a study. They were asked to name a co-worker and then -- after an "emotion induction" phase -- answer a series of questions about that person. In the "emotion induction" phase, participants recounted in writing an incident that made them angry, sad, or happy (depending on which emotion they were assigned). Participants wrote about events like the birth of a child (happiness), the untimely death of a loved one (sadness), or the destructive behavior of a neighbor (anger). After this exercise, participants rated their co-workers on such statements as: "If X promised to copy a presentation for me, s/he would follow through," and "X would never intentionally misrepresent my point of view to others." Results showed that happy participants were significantly more trusting than were sad participants, and sad participants were significantly more trusting than were angry participants. Throughout each of the five studies, the results were the same. "What surprised me most was the magnitude and consistency of the effects," says Schweitzer.
A "Simple Manipulation"
For managers, this study reveals much about human nature, he suggests. "We can easily channel people and direct them to a happy, sad or angry place ... in a relatively short period of time with a relatively simple manipulation." These manipulations can take the form of a short story (e.g., a news story), a short movie clip, or even a short discussion. For example, the best salespeople "don't call on a customer and start with a comment about the stock market dropping or a favorite sports team losing. Instead, they focus attention on something uplifting," like a team making the playoffs or an upcoming holiday.
"In negotiation, we have always known that non-task communication -- discussion that's not directly relevant to the negotiation process -- is important for closing a deal," says Schweitzer. "This research gives us some insight into why it's important and what kinds of things should go into that communication." Specifically, "non-task communication, like telling jokes/stories or talking about sports, can change people's emotional states and make them more (or less) trusting. My advice is to give serious thought to non-task communication. This includes preparing the types of stories you tell and the types of non-task questions you ask. It also includes learning more about a client, such as whether he/she is a huge Red Sox fan or cares a lot about wildlife refuges. Conversely, you should recognize that when a salesperson or someone else engages in a conversation like this, he or she may influence your emotional state and subsequently your 'trust judgment'. The reason you gave someone a large contract may have more to do with how funny the story he told you beforehand was than with his reputation for dependability."
So going in to ask for a promotion or new responsibilities on the job is probably a good time to recount a funny story or ask about your supervisor's golf game, Schweitzer says. The point is to recognize the role that emotions play. Outside events -- such as the rise/fall of IBM stock if your supervisor owns it, or whether his or her child got accepted into a prestigious college -- as well as non-task communication, like telling a funny story, are important for trust judgments.
That's not to say we should never acknowledge problems that occur outside of the work setting, Schweitzer adds. "You have to demonstrate sensitivity." If a colleague is going through a difficult time personally, you should acknowledge it, but not dwell on it. "Our research shows that you can shift people to think about happy things and make them -- literally -- happy."
What Schweitzer and Dunn don't know is how long these incidental emotions last. The research tested people's propensity to trust immediately after the emotion induction (putting people into a happy, sad, or angry mood). Schweitzer is now working on a series of tests to determine the durability of these emotions: Do they last for minutes, hours, days or weeks? The results should help fill out the picture of how emotions affect our judgments.
Being Aware of Your Emotions
A second key finding in the study is that if people are aware of their emotional state, then the emotional state does not generally bleed into their judgments of others. In one study, for example, participants were shown film clips to induce either happiness or anger. Participants in the "happy" group watched a Robin Williams comedy routine, while those in the "anger" group watched a clip from the film Witness, in which teenagers harass an Amish man. After watching the clips, half of those in the "happy" group saw a brief note on screen that read, "Prior research has shown that even short film clips like the ones you have seen can influence people's emotions." The other half saw a blank screen. This was duplicated in the "angry" group. Consistent with the other study, angry participants provided significantly lower trust ratings than happy participants among those who did not receive the warning message. Among those who viewed the warning message, trust levels were about the same.
Again, says Schweitzer, links to the business world are clear, in particular because the results speak directly to the issue of "emotional intelligence," a widely discussed concept in recent years. "Managers and employees alike need to realize that when making decisions, they are in a state that is driven partly by reason, but also partly by emotion," he notes. Taking into account the role of awareness, managers can keep an eye out for employees who are at risk for bringing unrelated emotions to critical decisions. For example, a manager in a law firm may need to pull another lawyer aside and say, "I know case X isn't going well, but case Y is different," or "I know you're going through a difficult divorce, but don't let that cloud your judgment when you go into your negotiations today." Says Schweitzer: "When people recognize the trigger, or source, of their emotions they are less likely to misattribute them. When I realize that I'm angry because of something my spouse did, I am less likely to use that anger in an unrelated judgment. When I am not aware of or thinking about why I am angry, I am more likely to misattribute it."
Unattributed emotions are a problem, he points out, particularly for people working in high-stress, fast-paced jobs, like judges and parole officers, who have to make quick judgments about people. Because they move from one incident to the next without the luxury of time to sit back and gauge their emotions, they are more likely to misattribute emotional states. Again, awareness and correct attribution of emotional states can help manage this process, he suggests.
Based on his work in the field, Schweitzer thinks people conceive of themselves as rational human beings driven by rational thought -- particularly Westerners -- but it's not true. "People undervalue the extent to which emotions influence their judgment," he says. Correctly attributing our emotional states can counter the effects of others who are trying to manipulate our feelings. "Good sales people tell jokes and funny stories; they bring little gifts. What they are trying to do is influence people's emotional states." Recognizing that this person is trying to make you feel good can help separate the good feelings from the decisions at hand. Are you feeling you can trust these new partners and sign on the dotted line because it's a solid deal or because you are ecstatic over your new baby? "This is what we need to be aware of," says Schweitzer.
The highly emotional people in the crowd shouldn't feel too bad, he adds, noting that our quick emotional reactions have served us well for the past 100,000 years. Our ancestors who happened upon a snarling, big-toothed animal were smart to listen to their emotions and run the other way. "Actually, it's only been fairly recently that we can or should override those emotional reactions," he says. In other words, going into battle mode may not be the best response to a large, scary-looking person coming toward you at work. Especially if it's your boss.
SOURCE:http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu
THANKS,
AJIT CHOUHAN
Tuesday, July 12, 2005
Great Managers Understand Their People
Great Managers Understand Their People
Average managers treat all their employees the same. Great managers discover each individual's unique talents and bring these to the surface so everyone wins. An excerpt from Harvard Business Review.
by Marcus Buckingham
"The best boss I ever had." That's a phrase most of us have said or heard at some point, but what does it mean? What sets the great boss apart from the average boss? The literature is rife with provocative writing about the qualities of managers and leaders and whether the two differ, but little has been said about what happens in the thousands of daily interactions and decisions that allows managers to get the best out of their people and win their devotion. What do great managers actually do?
In my research, beginning with a survey of 80,000 managers conducted by the Gallup Organization and continuing during the past two years with in-depth studies of a few top performers, I've found that while there are as many styles of managers, there is one quality that sets truly great managers apart from the rest: They discover what is unique about each person and then capitalize on it. Average managers play checkers, while great managers play chess. The difference? In checkers, all the pieces are uniform and move in the same way; they are interchangeable. You need to plan and coordinate their movements, certainly, but they all move at the same pace, on parallel paths. In chess, each type of piece moves in a different way, and you can't play if you don't know how each piece moves. More important, you won't win if you don't think carefully about how you move the pieces. Great managers know and value the unique abilities and even the eccentricities of their employees, and they learn how best to integrate them into a coordinated plan of attack.
This is the exact opposite of what great leaders do. Great leaders discover what is universal and capitalize on it. Their job is to rally people toward a better future. Leaders can succeed in this only when they can cut through differences of race, sex, age, nationality, and personality and, using stories and celebrating heroes, tap into those very few needs we all share. The job of a manager, meanwhile, is to turn one person's particular talent into performance. Managers will succeed only when they can identify and deploy the differences among people, challenging each employee to excel in his or her own way. This doesn't mean a leader can't be a manager or vice versa. But to excel at one or both, you must be aware of the very different skills each role requires. [...]
Managers will succeed only when they can identify and deploy the differences among people. Make the most of strengths. It takes time and effort to gain a full appreciation of an employee's strengths and weaknesses. The great manager spends a good deal of time outside the office walking around, watching each person's reactions to events, listening, and taking mental notes about what each individual is drawn to and what each person struggles with. There's no substitute for this kind of observation, but you can obtain a lot of information about a person by asking a few simple, open-ended questions and listening carefully to the answers. Two queries in particular have proven most revealing when it comes to identifying strengths and weaknesses, and I recommend asking them of all new hires—and revisiting the questions periodically.
To identify a person's strengths, first ask, "What was the best day at work you've had in the past three months?" Find out what the person was doing and why he enjoyed it so much. Remember: A strength is not merely something you are good at. In fact, it might be something you aren't good at yet. It might be just a predilection, something you find so intrinsically satisfying that you look forward to doing it again and again and getting better at it over time. This question will prompt your employee to start thinking about his interests and abilities from this perspective.
To identify a person's weakness, just invert the question: "What was the worst day you've had at work in the past three months?" And then probe for details about what he was doing and why it grated on him so much. As with a strength, a weakness is not merely something you are bad at (in fact, you might be quite competent at it). It is something that drains you of energy, an activity that you never look forward to doing and that when you are doing it, all you can think about is stopping.
Although you're keeping an eye out for both the strengths and weaknesses of your employees, your focus should be on their strengths. Conventional wisdom holds that self-awareness is a good thing and that it's the job of the manager to identify weaknesses and create a plan for overcoming them. But research by Albert Bandura, the father of social learning theory, has shown that self-assurance (labeled "self-efficacy" by cognitive psychologists), not self-awareness, is the strongest predictor of a person's ability to set high goals, to persist in the face of obstacles, to bounce back when reversals occur, and, ultimately, to achieve the goals they set. By contrast, self-awareness has not been shown to be a predictor of any of these outcomes, and in some cases, it appears to retard them.
Great managers seem to understand this instinctively. They know that their job is not to arm each employee with a dispassionately accurate understanding of the limits of her strengths and the liabilities of her weaknesses but to reinforce her self-assurance. That's why great managers focus on strengths. When a person succeeds, the great manager doesn't praise her hard work. Even if there is some exaggeration in the statement, he tells her that she succeeded because she has become so good at deploying her specific strengths. This, the manager knows, will strengthen the employee's self-assurance and make her more optimistic and more resilient in the face of challenges to come.
You can obtain a lot of information about a person by asking a few simple, open-ended questions. The focus-on-strengths approach might create in the employee a modicum of overconfidence, but great managers mitigate this by emphasizing the size and the difficulty of the employee's goals. They know that their primary objective is to create in each employee a specific state of mind: one that includes a realistic assessment of the difficulty of the obstacle ahead but an unrealistically optimistic belief in her ability to overcome it.
And what if the employee fails? Assuming the failure is not attributable to factors beyond her control, always explain failure as a lack of effort, even if this is only partially accurate. This will obscure self-doubt and give her something to work on as she faces up to the next challenge.
Repeated failure, of course, may indicate weakness where a role requires strength. In such cases, there are four approaches for overcoming weaknesses. If the problem amounts to lack of skill or knowledge, that's easy to solve: Simply offer the relevant training, allow some time for the employee to incorporate the new skills, and look for signs of improvement. If her performance doesn't get better, you'll know that the reason she's struggling is because she is missing certain talents, a deficit no amount of skill or knowledge training is likely to fix. You'll have to find a way to manage around this weakness and neutralize it.
Which brings us to the second strategy for overcoming an employee weakness. Can you find her a partner, someone whose talents are strong in precisely the areas where hers are weak? Here's how this strategy can look in action. As vice president of merchandising for the women's clothing retailer Ann Taylor, Judi Langley found that tensions were rising between her and one of her merchandising managers, Claudia (not her real name), whose analytical mind and intense nature created an overpowering "need to know." If Claudia learned of something before Judi had a chance to review it with her, she would become deeply frustrated. Given the speed with which decisions were made, and given Judy's busy schedule, this happened frequently. Judi was concerned that Claudia's irritation was unsettling to the whole product team, not to mention earning the employee a reputation as a malcontent.
Always explain failure as a lack of effort, even if this is only partially accurate.
An average manager might have identified this behavior as a weakness and lectured Claudia on how to control her need for information. Judi, however, realized that this "weakness" was an aspect of Claudia's greatest strength: her analytical mind. Claudia would never be able to rein it in, at least not for long. So Judi looked for a strategy that would honor and support Claudia's need to know, while channeling it more productively. Judi decided to act as Claudia's information partner, and she committed to leaving Claudia a voice mail at the end of each day with a brief update. To make sure nothing fell through the cracks, they set up two live "touch base" conversations per week. This solution managed Claudia's expectations and assured her that she would get the information she needed, if not exactly when she wanted it, then at least at frequent and predictable intervals. Giving Claudia a partner neutralized the negative manifestations of her strength, allowing her to focus her analytical mind on her work. (Of course, in most cases, the partner would need to be someone other than a manager.)
Should the perfect partner prove hard to find, try this third strategy: Insert into the employee's world a technique that helps accomplish through discipline what the person can't accomplish through instinct. I met one very successful screenwriter and director who had struggled with telling other professionals, such as composers and directors of photography, that their work was not up to snuff. So he devised a mental trick: He now imagines what the "god of art" would want and uses this imaginary entity as a source of strength. In his mind, he no longer imposes his own opinion on his colleagues but rather tells himself (and them) that an authoritative third party has weighed in.
If training produces no improvement, if complementary partnering proves impractical, and if no nifty discipline technique can be found, you are going to have to try the fourth and final strategy, which is to rearrange the employee's working world to render his weakness irrelevant. This strategy will require of you, first, the creativity to envision a more effective arrangement and, second, the courage to make that arrangement work. But the payoff that may come in the form of increased employee productivity and engagement is well worth it.
Excerpted with permission from "What Great Managers Do," Harvard Business Review, Vol. 83, No. 3, March 2005.
Marcus Buckingham (info@onethinginc.com) is a consultant and speaker on leadership and management practices.
Ajit Chouhan
Average managers treat all their employees the same. Great managers discover each individual's unique talents and bring these to the surface so everyone wins. An excerpt from Harvard Business Review.
by Marcus Buckingham
"The best boss I ever had." That's a phrase most of us have said or heard at some point, but what does it mean? What sets the great boss apart from the average boss? The literature is rife with provocative writing about the qualities of managers and leaders and whether the two differ, but little has been said about what happens in the thousands of daily interactions and decisions that allows managers to get the best out of their people and win their devotion. What do great managers actually do?
In my research, beginning with a survey of 80,000 managers conducted by the Gallup Organization and continuing during the past two years with in-depth studies of a few top performers, I've found that while there are as many styles of managers, there is one quality that sets truly great managers apart from the rest: They discover what is unique about each person and then capitalize on it. Average managers play checkers, while great managers play chess. The difference? In checkers, all the pieces are uniform and move in the same way; they are interchangeable. You need to plan and coordinate their movements, certainly, but they all move at the same pace, on parallel paths. In chess, each type of piece moves in a different way, and you can't play if you don't know how each piece moves. More important, you won't win if you don't think carefully about how you move the pieces. Great managers know and value the unique abilities and even the eccentricities of their employees, and they learn how best to integrate them into a coordinated plan of attack.
This is the exact opposite of what great leaders do. Great leaders discover what is universal and capitalize on it. Their job is to rally people toward a better future. Leaders can succeed in this only when they can cut through differences of race, sex, age, nationality, and personality and, using stories and celebrating heroes, tap into those very few needs we all share. The job of a manager, meanwhile, is to turn one person's particular talent into performance. Managers will succeed only when they can identify and deploy the differences among people, challenging each employee to excel in his or her own way. This doesn't mean a leader can't be a manager or vice versa. But to excel at one or both, you must be aware of the very different skills each role requires. [...]
Managers will succeed only when they can identify and deploy the differences among people. Make the most of strengths. It takes time and effort to gain a full appreciation of an employee's strengths and weaknesses. The great manager spends a good deal of time outside the office walking around, watching each person's reactions to events, listening, and taking mental notes about what each individual is drawn to and what each person struggles with. There's no substitute for this kind of observation, but you can obtain a lot of information about a person by asking a few simple, open-ended questions and listening carefully to the answers. Two queries in particular have proven most revealing when it comes to identifying strengths and weaknesses, and I recommend asking them of all new hires—and revisiting the questions periodically.
To identify a person's strengths, first ask, "What was the best day at work you've had in the past three months?" Find out what the person was doing and why he enjoyed it so much. Remember: A strength is not merely something you are good at. In fact, it might be something you aren't good at yet. It might be just a predilection, something you find so intrinsically satisfying that you look forward to doing it again and again and getting better at it over time. This question will prompt your employee to start thinking about his interests and abilities from this perspective.
To identify a person's weakness, just invert the question: "What was the worst day you've had at work in the past three months?" And then probe for details about what he was doing and why it grated on him so much. As with a strength, a weakness is not merely something you are bad at (in fact, you might be quite competent at it). It is something that drains you of energy, an activity that you never look forward to doing and that when you are doing it, all you can think about is stopping.
Although you're keeping an eye out for both the strengths and weaknesses of your employees, your focus should be on their strengths. Conventional wisdom holds that self-awareness is a good thing and that it's the job of the manager to identify weaknesses and create a plan for overcoming them. But research by Albert Bandura, the father of social learning theory, has shown that self-assurance (labeled "self-efficacy" by cognitive psychologists), not self-awareness, is the strongest predictor of a person's ability to set high goals, to persist in the face of obstacles, to bounce back when reversals occur, and, ultimately, to achieve the goals they set. By contrast, self-awareness has not been shown to be a predictor of any of these outcomes, and in some cases, it appears to retard them.
Great managers seem to understand this instinctively. They know that their job is not to arm each employee with a dispassionately accurate understanding of the limits of her strengths and the liabilities of her weaknesses but to reinforce her self-assurance. That's why great managers focus on strengths. When a person succeeds, the great manager doesn't praise her hard work. Even if there is some exaggeration in the statement, he tells her that she succeeded because she has become so good at deploying her specific strengths. This, the manager knows, will strengthen the employee's self-assurance and make her more optimistic and more resilient in the face of challenges to come.
You can obtain a lot of information about a person by asking a few simple, open-ended questions. The focus-on-strengths approach might create in the employee a modicum of overconfidence, but great managers mitigate this by emphasizing the size and the difficulty of the employee's goals. They know that their primary objective is to create in each employee a specific state of mind: one that includes a realistic assessment of the difficulty of the obstacle ahead but an unrealistically optimistic belief in her ability to overcome it.
And what if the employee fails? Assuming the failure is not attributable to factors beyond her control, always explain failure as a lack of effort, even if this is only partially accurate. This will obscure self-doubt and give her something to work on as she faces up to the next challenge.
Repeated failure, of course, may indicate weakness where a role requires strength. In such cases, there are four approaches for overcoming weaknesses. If the problem amounts to lack of skill or knowledge, that's easy to solve: Simply offer the relevant training, allow some time for the employee to incorporate the new skills, and look for signs of improvement. If her performance doesn't get better, you'll know that the reason she's struggling is because she is missing certain talents, a deficit no amount of skill or knowledge training is likely to fix. You'll have to find a way to manage around this weakness and neutralize it.
Which brings us to the second strategy for overcoming an employee weakness. Can you find her a partner, someone whose talents are strong in precisely the areas where hers are weak? Here's how this strategy can look in action. As vice president of merchandising for the women's clothing retailer Ann Taylor, Judi Langley found that tensions were rising between her and one of her merchandising managers, Claudia (not her real name), whose analytical mind and intense nature created an overpowering "need to know." If Claudia learned of something before Judi had a chance to review it with her, she would become deeply frustrated. Given the speed with which decisions were made, and given Judy's busy schedule, this happened frequently. Judi was concerned that Claudia's irritation was unsettling to the whole product team, not to mention earning the employee a reputation as a malcontent.
Always explain failure as a lack of effort, even if this is only partially accurate.
An average manager might have identified this behavior as a weakness and lectured Claudia on how to control her need for information. Judi, however, realized that this "weakness" was an aspect of Claudia's greatest strength: her analytical mind. Claudia would never be able to rein it in, at least not for long. So Judi looked for a strategy that would honor and support Claudia's need to know, while channeling it more productively. Judi decided to act as Claudia's information partner, and she committed to leaving Claudia a voice mail at the end of each day with a brief update. To make sure nothing fell through the cracks, they set up two live "touch base" conversations per week. This solution managed Claudia's expectations and assured her that she would get the information she needed, if not exactly when she wanted it, then at least at frequent and predictable intervals. Giving Claudia a partner neutralized the negative manifestations of her strength, allowing her to focus her analytical mind on her work. (Of course, in most cases, the partner would need to be someone other than a manager.)
Should the perfect partner prove hard to find, try this third strategy: Insert into the employee's world a technique that helps accomplish through discipline what the person can't accomplish through instinct. I met one very successful screenwriter and director who had struggled with telling other professionals, such as composers and directors of photography, that their work was not up to snuff. So he devised a mental trick: He now imagines what the "god of art" would want and uses this imaginary entity as a source of strength. In his mind, he no longer imposes his own opinion on his colleagues but rather tells himself (and them) that an authoritative third party has weighed in.
If training produces no improvement, if complementary partnering proves impractical, and if no nifty discipline technique can be found, you are going to have to try the fourth and final strategy, which is to rearrange the employee's working world to render his weakness irrelevant. This strategy will require of you, first, the creativity to envision a more effective arrangement and, second, the courage to make that arrangement work. But the payoff that may come in the form of increased employee productivity and engagement is well worth it.
Excerpted with permission from "What Great Managers Do," Harvard Business Review, Vol. 83, No. 3, March 2005.
Marcus Buckingham (info@onethinginc.com) is a consultant and speaker on leadership and management practices.
Ajit Chouhan
Saturday, July 09, 2005
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)